Deer-Resistant Plants
Feeding Habits of Deer
-
The notion for any
plant to be deer proof is mythical. Hungry deer, as they were this
winter, will eat almost anything. This winter they literally
stripped the bark from the trees. The hungrier and more desperate
they become, the more they are likely to browse or at least try some of
their least favorites. While the deer are experimenting, they will
often chew off and spit out pieces of plants that are supposed to be
virtually deer proof. In the process, of course, they disfigure the
plant.
A
plant is particularly subject to danger at the end of winter and whenever
the new growth is tender.
In general, deer will not jump over anything they can’t see over.
In
landscaping the yard, it is wise to remember that deer ritually follow
certain pathways everyday. It is wise to put the more tempting plants
away from these pathways. In some yards deer will not cross hard surfaces
such as walks and driveways. Sometimes it is even possible to design a
portion of the landscape comprised of tall plants that deer generally
avoid. This can create kind of a hallway that deer can use as they cross
through your yard. It is not easy to accomplish, but it is sometimes
possible.
There
are all kinds of “repellents” (human hair, bars of soap and playing
radios) that people find to keep deer away from their plants. Deer
quickly adjust to all of these “repellents”, and no single one seems to be
reliable for more than a few weeks. Change is the key for these supposed
repellents to work at all. I find the best repellent to be a monthly
application of Milorganite fertilizer. Milorganite is made from the sewer
sludge from the city of Milwaukee, where there are several major beer
breweries. Rumor has it that Milorganite has a slight essence of both
beer and humans, which the deer associate with hunters. Whatever the
case, it does seem to work - at least over the growing season months.
Sprays, although they have to be re-applied every few weeks (depending on
the rain), are effective for short periods. Ropel and Tree Guard have
worked the best for us. Securely netting the shrubs, especially in the
winter, with almost-invisible black plastic netting can work effectively.
Evidently, deer wish to avoid the sensation of their teeth getting tangled
in the netting. Repellex tablets, though expensive, are an excellent long
term repellent.
To
confuse things even more, deer have regional taste preferences. What they
will eat in one neighborhood they will avoid in another. Some plants
which are particularly subject to regional taste preferences are: white
pine, holly (except American holly), aucuba, deciduous magnolias, cornus
mas, camellias, nandina, Japanese maples and birds nest spruce.
A
species that deer will browse as a newly planted small plant will often be
left untouched as a mature, established plant.
|
|